Skip to content

Menu

Copyright Teaching and Learning Blog 2023 | Theme by ThemeinProgress | Proudly powered by WordPress

Teaching and Learning BlogIncorporating the E-learning Blog

Twenty tips for interpreting scientific claims

Nature journal logo
November 22, 2013Comment piece Standard

Nature journal logoThe journal Nature has this week published an interesting comment piece aimed specifically at educating politicians about the scientific approach to data but which could just as easily be used for many different types of data.  The “twenty tips” are as useful in helping us remember how to judge educational data and to avoid simple conclusions to complex issues.

Of the twenty tips worth thinking about with regard to education, I highlight the following:

Differences and chance cause variation –  when students sit their assessments makes a difference, remember the hayfever season!

No measurement is exact – as the article says, “practically all measurements have some errors. If the measurement process were repeated, one might record a different result”

Bias is rife – think about what assessments (for example) you are setting and for whom. How will this affect the outcomes?

Extrapolating beyond the data is risky – how many times have we read that a whole area of the curriculum/cohort of students is view in the same way?

Scientists are human – they have vested interests in promoting a specific position – also applies to academics, managers, probably everyone!

Read the whole article and see what you think.

Categories

  • Academic misconduct
  • Academic skills
  • Accessibility
  • Adobe Connect
  • AR
  • Assessment
  • Assessment and feedback
  • Audio
  • Blackboard Collaborate
  • Blended learning
  • BoB Box of Broadcasts
  • Camtasia
  • Case Studies
  • Co-Tutor
  • Collaboration
  • Comment piece
  • Communications
  • Conferences
  • Copyright
  • CPD
  • Current Projects
  • Digital literacy
  • Distance learning
  • E-portfolios
  • Electronic Voting
  • Elluminate
  • Employability
  • Engagement
  • Evaluation
  • Events
  • Excellence in Teaching and Learning
  • Facebook
  • Feedback
  • Fieldwork
  • Flipped classroom
  • Funding
  • Futurelearn
  • Gamification
  • General
  • Groupwork
  • HE trends
  • HEA
  • Images
  • Informal learning
  • Innovation
  • iPads
  • JISC
  • Learn
  • Lecture capture
  • LectureTools
  • Lecturing to large groups
  • Make History timelines
  • Microsoft Teams
  • Minimum Presence
  • Mobile devices
  • Module and curriculum design
  • MOOCs
  • Moodle
  • New lecturers
  • NSS
  • OER
  • OMR
  • Online marking
  • Online submission
  • PDP
  • Pedagogic
  • Pedagogic research
  • Pedagogy
  • Peer Support
  • Personal tutoring
  • Plagiarism
  • Podcasting
  • Programme Reps
  • QR codes
  • Quiz
  • Reports
  • Research into e-learning
  • Researchers
  • ReVIEW (Echo 360)
  • RiTA
  • RITAs
  • Screen recording
  • Second Life
  • Smartpens
  • Social media
  • Staff Development
  • Standards
  • Strategy
  • Student-led curriculum
  • Support for students
  • Tablets
  • Teaching Awards
  • Teaching excellence
  • Teaching Innovation Awards
  • Teaching methods
  • Teaching room technologies
  • Teaching rooms
  • TechWatch
  • Tools
  • Turnitin
  • Twitter
  • Uncategorized
  • Vacancies
  • Vevox
  • Vice Chancellor's Award
  • Video
  • Web 2.0
  • Web Conferencing
  • WebPA
  • widening participation